AA Vehicle Rates Calculator

Rates Calculator

Roadside Assistance

Roadside Assistance

Emergency Services

Emergency Services

AA Auto Centre

AA Auto Centre

AA Financial Services

AA Financial Services

AA Travel

AA Travel

Call me backCALL ME BACK

I need help choosing a product


Association says Gautrain is a white elephant which cannot be allowed to become more bloated

View the full AA Submission on Gautrain Extensions here.

Proposed route extensions to the Gautrain must be rejected by the Gauteng Provincial Government as they will perpetuate a system which caters for the minority of citizens in the province who don’t need it, instead of the mass market which does. This call on the provincial government is contained in a detailed submission of the Automobile Association (AA) made today in relation to the proposed extensions of the Gauteng Rapid Rail Integrated Network, or simply, the Gautrain.

In its submission the AA highlights several key factors which it believes negate the extension of Gautrain, among them the fact that the current demand of the system is low, and that economic viability cannot be established within reasonable risk parameters.

“Simply put, the Gautrain doesn’t carry enough passengers currently, certainly not as many as it had projected when it started. Spending valuable financial resources now to continue with a system that doesn’t have a demand, at the expense of better, more efficient, and more affordable transport does not make any sense. We are in favour of alternatives that provide solutions to vehicle usage, and which reduce pollution and congestion, but the Gautrain is not that solution,” says the AA.

And, says the AA, low usage of the Gautrain puts additional pressure on the province’s Transport Budget which effectively means other transport options are not properly funded, again disadvantaging the mass market which needs it most.

“The so-called Patronage Guarantee is a mechanism whereby Bombela – the concessionaire which operates Gautrain – is compensated for sub-par ridership levels of their trains. This means they can rely on the Gauteng Provincial Government as a funder of last resort regardless of how well or badly their business fares. It’s a disgraceful and outrageous agreement which has cost taxpayers close on R12bn since 2012 just because not enough people see value in using the Gautrain,” says the AA.

The Association notes that because of the Patronage Guarantee which is, effectively, built-in insurance for poor performance, less money is available for more effective methods of mass transit which can convey many more people in a more flexible way and a lower cost.

Instead, the AA urges, the Gauteng Provincial Government should invest heavily in the creation of a provincial-scale bus system as the most appropriate solution to mass transit in Gauteng. The provision of safe cycle lanes and solutions for those who walk the ‘last mile’ to work and home must also be considered. This, the AA says, has inexpensive infrastructure requirements, and will integrate with all other modes of transport. It will also encourage non-motorised transport, and bring cost-effective travel within reach of all citizens.

“In the years leading up to Cabinet’s approval of Gautrain in 2005, many different individuals, groups and organisations, including the then Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Transport, raised concerns that Gautrain was neither a financially sound nor a sustainable investment. Almost two decades later, these concerns have been realised and instead of solving the province’s dire transport crisis, Gautrain has become a system for the well-off who in any event have access to other modes of transport,” notes the AA.

The Association says these issues highlight just some of its concerns and that many more are included in its submission. Among these are, according to the Association, unsubstantiated projections of the economic benefits Gautrain has had on areas surrounding the stations, the lack of identifiable target riders for new routes, and the high costs of expropriating the land to build the extensions on

“On all counts the Gautrain is a failed system as far as providing a mass transit solution for the people of the province. It will continue to be a failed system the longer it remains so heavily subsidised by taxpayers at the expense of reliable, efficient and affordable transport solutions. To extend the Gautrain services now is economically inappropriate and unacceptable, and the process should be halted immediately,” the AA concludes.


Tools & Calculators
What is your Emergency?
The Automobile Association of South Africa

For over 90 years, we’ve provided you with roadside rescue and security, so you know you can rely on the Automobile Association day and night.

We aim to empower you as a road user and add value to your life with our products and services.

Decrease in fatalities welcome – but more needs to be done

The small decrease in the number of fatalities on South African roads between the December 2022 and January 2023 festive period and the 2023/2024 period is commendable and signals a slight improvement in road safety efforts by authorities. However, the Automobile Association (AA) remains concerned that the deaths of 1427 road users during the festive period is still too high, and that more needs to be done to effectively deal with road safety in South Africa. Transport Minister Sindisiwe...

2024 to start on positive fuel note for consumers

Despite the volatile Rand and concerns around shipping routes in the Red Sea, local fuel prices are still expected to decrease when they are adjusted by the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy next Wednesday. Commenting on unaudited data from the Central Energy Fund (CEF), the Automobile Association (AA) says the numbers are still pointing to reductions to fuel prices across the board.   According to the CEF’s figures, ULP95 petrol is expected to be lower by around 54cents a litre while...

Good fuel news for motorists to start 2024

South African motorists can expect significant fuel price reductions to kick-off 2024 says the Automobile Association (AA). Commenting on unaudited data from the Central Energy Fund (CEF), the AA says both grades of petrol, diesel, and illuminating paraffin prices are showing substantial decreases that will ease the financial pressure on consumers in January. “According to the data, ULP93 will decrease by around 68 cents/litre, and ULP95 will decrease by 82c/l. Diesel is set to decrease...